List of Accused Priests in North Dakota
Clergy sexual violence within the Dakota Catholic Diocese has left a deep mark on countless lives. For several decades, substantiated allegations have exposed the extensive nature of the misconduct and the emotional scars inflicted on survivors.
Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers are committed to providing unwavering support for these survivors. Our mission is to hold the Catholic Church accountable while promising a pathway to help these victims overcome this devastating issue.
Table of Contents
| Last Name | First Name | Diocese | Status | Accusations (Summary) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Becwar | Earl J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died 9/5/91. |
| Dukart | Norman J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Transferred to Crosby ND in 1999, told Parish of history of sexual abuse, but Bishop Zipfel would not remove him. Many parishioners left the parish, returning only after Dukart was removed in 3/02. |
| Frank | Father | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Sued | A man filed suit in federal court in 12/09 against a priest assigned to St. Joseph Church and School in Mandan, ND. |
| Gustin | Theodore F. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Parish priest. Held chancery positions, including as long-time Tribunal official. Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 6/18/02. Died 12/27/06. |
| Haspert | Eugene J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Died 7/3/79. Allegations reported after his death. Substantiated. |
| Heinen | Victor J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the Bismarck diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations reported after his death. Substantiated. Died 6/24/53. Added to the Conception Abbey Benedictines list in 4/20. |
| Hill | Donald W. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 1/6/03. Died 11/21/04. |
| Kuhn | John Herman | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died 3/15/06. |
| Krank | Michael T. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 3/11/04. Died 11/28/10. |
| McGovern | Hugh C. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations reported after McGovern’s death. Substantiated. Died 7/22/88. |
| McNeely | Maurice G. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Settled | McNeely was ordained for the Diocese of Bismarck and worked at Holy Family Catholic Academy in Honolulu and Las Vegas before retiring to MI. A woman claimed he abused her late husband in ND in the 1960s. |
| Muggli | Odo | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Assumption Abbey Benedictine in Richardton, ND, received a report in 1991 of allegations against Muggli, who has since been on a “safety plan”. |
| Nelson | Frederic J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 2/20/84. Died 8/13/88. |
| Meyer | Charles | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Meyer was named publicly as accused by several dioceses, including the Bismarck diocese, the La Crosse diocese, the Diocese of Wichita, and the Diocese of St. Cloud. |
| Owens | John J. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Owens was ordained for the Diocese of Bismarck and fill-in for Archdiocese of St. Paul-Minneapolis near Forest Lake, but was named publicly as accused by the St. Paul-Minneapolis archdiocese on its list 10/23/14, for abuse in the Bismarck diocese. |
| Pommier | James W. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Settled | In the 1960s and 1970s, several allegations were made against Pommier. In 1985, his faculties were removed by the archbishop, and in 1990, he was laicized by the Vatican for “ecclesiastical crimes against youth”. |
| Reardon | James E. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 4/16/02. Died 3/11/07. |
| Simon | Aloysius P. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Accused of sexual misconduct by the Bismarck diocese, he was permanently removed from the faculty in 1985. |
| Spegele | Michael A. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Several dioceses have named and accused priests of sexual misconduct. One allegation has been substantiated in the KC-St Joseph diocese. |
| Talty | Laurence R. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the Bismarck diocese on its list 1/2/20. Died 8/22/89. |
| Wuest | Robert | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the Bismarck diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations made after his death. Substantiated. Died 3/26/88. |
| Zastoupil | Stephen R. | Diocese of Bismarck ND | Accused | After years of counseling, he was removed from parish assignment because of ‘misconduct’ involving two children 31 years prior. He died 7/2/18. |
| Amiott | William K. | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Removed from ministry. Laicized. |
| Binder | Julius | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1991. |
| Belleau | Jules | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | The diocese named Belleau publicly as accused on its list 1/2/2020. Allegations substantiated. |
| Anthony | Abraham | Diocese of Fargo ND | Charged | From the Diocese of Simla-Chandigarh, India. Charged with gross sexual imposition, sexual assault, and disorderly conduct, but the charges were dropped before he could be questioned. |
| Burque | Lucien | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1976. |
| Conlon | Timothy C. | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Conlon was removed from two AZ parishes by the Gallup Diocese after two credible allegations were received from the Fargo ND diocese regarding abuse prior to ordination. He was a Crosier brother at the time in question. |
| Cullen | Martin | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Cullen was named publicly as accused by the diocese and removed from ministry in 1992. He told a reporter that he sexually abused two children. |
| Feeney | Robert E. | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Faculties permanently removed 4/17/02. Died 4/3/06. |
| Feltman | Thomas | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Suspended 5/17 after complaints of inappropriate activities with youth. Feltman denied wrongdoing, but the state’s attorney investigated and said he would not be charged. |
| Fish | Eugene | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Removed from ministry. Included on the Diocese of Lansing’s list in 11/20; noted to have credible allegations of abuse elsewhere and residing in the diocese. |
| Jr. | Charles Fischer, | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Admitted in 2/02 to sexual misconduct with children, recanted in 5/02, and was in residence at cathedral per diocese website 3/12. |
| Gallagher | Kenneth | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Removed from ministry. Laicized. Died in 2010. |
| Gonnelly | Theophane | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the Fargo diocese on its list 1/2/20, substantiated allegations, died 1/26/05. Musician, seminary teacher, magician, performed for youth at summer camp and missions. |
| Hagarty | Patrick | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | From the Omaha archdiocese. Named publicly as accused by the Fargo diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Deceased. |
| Herron | John B. | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | A woman accused Herron of sexually abusing her over a three-month period when she was a teenager in the 1970s. He was suspended pending civil and canonical investigations. |
| Jene | Alex | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1971. |
| Katanga | Wenceslaus | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | From Tanzania, Katanga attended the Pontifical College Josephinum in Columbus, OH. He was placed on leave in 4/19 during an investigation of an “interaction” with a minor, but the investigation was dropped due to lack of evidence. |
| Odor | Luke | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | From the Diocese of Aba, Nigeria, removed from chaplaincy at the V.A. hospital in Bedford, MA, and assigned to a Stowe, MA parish from 2007. |
| Picard | Laurent | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | From the Archdiocese of Grouard-McLennan, Canada. Named publicly as accused by the Fargo diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1989. |
| Patejko | Gregory | Diocese of Fargo ND | Settled | In 1984 a young man told a priest that Patejko had sexually molested him in 1976 in ND. In 1994 Fargo quietly settled with the alleged victim, and Patejko returned to Poland in 1993 and died in 1996. |
| Rausch | Cletus | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Deacon. Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Removed from ministry. |
| Roth | John | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1992. |
| Sayasaya | Fernando | Diocese of Fargo ND | Convicted | Educated overseas, ordained for the Fargo diocese, removed 8/98 after complaint of sex abuse, fled to Philippines in 12/98, charged 12/02 in U.S., extradited 4/2012, pleaded guilty to 2 counts, sentenced 10/1/18 to 20 years in prison. |
| Schwartz | Peter | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the Fargo diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 2003. |
| Sinner | Richard | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Removed from ministry in 1998. Died 1/28/2004. |
| Tuohy | John | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1960. |
| Storey | Allan | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Deacon. Worked in Walhalla. Barred from ministry in 2003 due to allegations of child sexual abuse. Allegations substantiated. Laicized. Included on the diocese’s list 1/2/20. |
| Vasques | George | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Removed from ministry. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1989. |
| Wanzek | John | Diocese of Fargo ND | Accused | Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 1/2/20. Allegations substantiated. Died in 1991. |
| Wild | David D. | Diocese of Fargo ND | Settled | Wild was removed from ministry in 1992 and three men filed lawsuits against him by 11/94. All three suits were settled in 12/94. |
About Clergy Sexual Abuse
Clergy sexual abuse refers to the sexual exploitation perpetrated by clergy members or church leaders, such as bishops and priests, in the abuse of a minor or other vulnerable people. The repercussions for the sexually abused victims are severe, often enduring psychological and emotional harm. Reporting these abuses and pursuing legal action is important to hold them accountable and avert further incidents.
Typically, the legal process in Dakota for cases involving sexual torture by a clergy member begins with reporting the violence to the authorities or the relevant diocesan officials. A comprehensive inquiry is conducted, and proof is diligently gathered. This process may culminate in filing a civil lawsuit or initiating a criminal investigation.
Legal Support for Survivors in North Dakota
At Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers, we promise extensive legal services that are tailored to survivors of alleged abuse. We assist with everything from collecting proof and filing claims to navigating court proceedings and negotiating settlements. With a strong track record in handling such sensitive cases, we are dedicated to fiercely advocating for your rights and helping you achieve the best possible outcome.
Laws and Regulations in North Dakota
In North Dakota, child sexual abuse cases are addressed by certain laws that provide a framework for legal recourse along with the protection of minor individuals.
Statute of Limitations: Survivors of clergy sexual abuse can file civil claims until age 36 or within three years of discovering the abuse, whichever is later. For criminal charges, if the complainant is aged between 15 and 18 years at the time of sexual assault, the statute of limitations would be 21 years, starting from the date when the last act of violence happened. In addition, the state also has a common law and statutory discovery rule that applies to substantiated claims of the abuse of a minor.
Mandatory Reporting Laws: In North Dakota, clergy members, among others, are required to report any suspicion of child abuse to authorities. This obligation helps ensure that abuse cases are promptly investigated and addressed.
Recent Legislative Changes: have aimed to extend the statute of limitations for civil and criminal cases, reflecting growing awareness and support for survivors. These updates provide more time for survivors to come forward and seek justice.
Filing a Clergy Sexual Abuse Lawsuit in North Dakota
Understanding the process of filing a clergy sex abuse lawsuit is an important step that can help streamline your legal journey.
Initial Consultation: Reach out to Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers for a confidential consultation. During this meeting, we will review your case, discuss the details of the assault, and outline the potential legal options available.
Gathering Evidence: Work with our legal team to compile and document all relevant proof. This report includes personal accounts, medical information, and any communications related to the assault. The more comprehensive the proof, the stronger your case will be.
Filing the Complaint: We will file a legal petition outlining your allegations and the damages you seek. This formal document initiates the legal process and informs the accused party of the substantiated claim against them.
Discovery Phase: Both the complainant and accused will then engage in the discovery process, exchanging proof and information to build their cases. This phase may include depositions, interrogatories, and requests for documents.
Negotiation and Settlement: Cases are most often resolved through settlement negotiations. We will work to reach a fair and just settlement that compensates you for the harm you have endured. If an agreement is reached, the case may be resolved without trial.
Trial: If a settlement cannot be agreed upon, your case will proceed to trial. During the trial, both parties will present their arguments before the jury, who will decide the outcome.
If you have been affected by sexual abuse in Dakota, contact Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers and get immediate professional assistance.
Support Resources for Survivors in North Dakota
Survivors of clergy sexual abuse in North Dakota can access various support resources to aid their recovery:
- North Dakota Sexual Assault Program (NDSAP)
Excels in providing crisis intervention and support services for survivors of sexual abuse. They also promise confidential assistance and multiple resources to help survivors steer through their recovery journey. - Rape and Abuse Crisis Center (RACC)
Located in Fargo, RACC provides counseling and advocacy services for survivors of sexual violence. Their services include trauma-informed therapy and legal advocacy. - North Dakota Coalition Against Sexual Assault (ND CASA)
Provides statewide support, including access to victim services, educational resources, and advocacy for sexual assault survivors. - National Sexual Assault Hotline
This hotline ensures immediate support and connects survivors with local services and resources. Available 24/7 at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or 1-800-472-2911. - Lutheran Social Services of North Dakota: Provides professional counseling for individuals dealing with trauma and abuse.
- Dakota Children’s Advocacy Center: Facilitates support groups for survivors and their families, providing a safe space for sharing experiences and peer support.
Remember, acquiring expert legal guidance paired with psychological therapy is extremely important to fully recover from the trauma of sexual abuse while also pursuing justice effectively.
Notable Cases and Outcomes in North Dakota
According to Bishop John Folda of the Fargo Diocese, the list of sexual violence cases in North Dakota has set important legal precedents and led to significant outcomes:
Norman Dukart, Michael Victor, Aloysius P. Simon, Eugene J. Haspert (Bismarck Diocese): Dukart and these other clergy members faced credible allegations of abusing minors. Their case contributed to heightened awareness and more rigorous legal scrutiny within the church regarding the protection of minors and addressing abuse allegations.
Fr. Herron John B. (Fargo Diocese): Ordained at St. Anthony, Herron John B. faced severe allegations that resulted in a thorough investigation, reinforcing the need for accountability within the Catholic Church.
John Owens, Armour R. Roberts, Donald W Hill, Steven R. Zastoupli, JR. Thomas S. Schaefer, Robert E Feeney, Lowell E. Fischer, and Odo Muggli: Each of these individuals faced credible allegations of child sexual abuse. Though many of them have passed away, the revelations from these cases led to significant legal and procedural changes aimed at safeguarding minors
Our attorneys have reviewed public and private settlement data related to North Dakota clergy abuse settlements. Depending on the circumstances pertaining to your case, these cases may be fairly valued in the $400,000 to $950,000 range. In cases of extreme conduct or if that case were to go before a jury, damages could exceed $1 million.
Why Choose Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers
Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers stands out as the premier choice for survivors of clergy sexual abuse due to our proven expertise and compassionate approach to justice. Our firm boasts a successful history of representing survivors and their families and achieving settlements that validate our credibility.
| $14 Million Priest grooming and handling | $4 Million Deacon assault and rape | $3 Million Clergy child abuse filed in adulthood |
| $3 Million Volunteer-perpetrated Catholic church abuse | $2 Million Religious school priest teen sexual abuse | $2 Million Clergy abuse case filed against a deceased priest |
We approach each case with sensitivity and respect, understanding the deep impact of sexual abuse on survivors. Our experienced legal team is committed to guiding clients through the legal process with empathy and professionalism, ensuring you feel supported at every step.
Contact Us
If you have been a victim of clergy sexual abuse, reach out to Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers for a confidential consultation. We are here to support and help you seek justice.
Phone: Call us at (888) 424-5757
Email: Contact us via email at info@rosenfeldinjurylaw.com
Contact Form: Visit our contact page to complete a confidential contact form.
All content undergoes thorough legal review by experienced attorneys, including Jonathan Rosenfeld. With 25 years of experience in personal injury law and over 100 years of combined legal expertise within our team, we ensure that every article is legally accurate, compliant, and reflects current legal standards.
